We have tallied your votes, and the audience favorite of Undercover series two shouldn’t surprise regular A.V. Club readers: They Might Be Giants, whose fan-assisted take on Chumbawumba’s “Tubthumping” was Undercover’s runaway hit. It was the landslide victor here.
Peter Bjorn And John (doing Otis Redding’s “Try A Little Tenderness”) took second, with Wye Oak (who memorably retooled Danzig’s “Mother”) rounding out the top three. Check out the full results below.
1. They Might Be Giants (3,786)
2. Peter Bjorn And John (2,084)
3. Wye Oak (1,717)
4. The Mountain Goats (1,600)
5. Iron & Wine (930)
6. Basia Bulat (717)
7. Of Montreal (664)
8. The Decemberists (576)
9. Low (572)
10. Rocky Votolato & Matt Pond PA (571)
11. Dum Dum Girls (557)
12. Sloan (518)
13. Sharon Van Etten (492)
14. Bob Mould (482)
15. Against Me! (479)
16. Parts & Labor (363)
17. The Low Anthem (315)
18. The Get Up Kids (287)
19. Baths (280)
20. Telekinesis (271)
21. The Hold Steady (265)
22. Fruit Bats (240)
23. Titus Andronicus (234)
24. Surfer Blood (204)
25. Matt Nathanson (173)
26. Smith Westerns (135)
27. …And You Will Know Us By The Trail Of Dead (133)
Stayed tuned for Holiday Undercover, coming in late November.