The 6 most scarily accurate parodies on Documentary Now!

What was meant to be a series by D.A. Pennebaker, became a single documentary about a Broadway show recording. The process, an attempt at preserving the ephemerality of theater, is a tense, claustrophobic experience in both the episode and the source. Co-written by musical lover John Mulaney, this one transforms Stephen Sondheim’s Company, a tale of Manhattanites and their romantic relationships, into Co-Op, a musical about the trials and tribulations of NYC apartment dwellings. Mulaney and co-writer Meyers up the ante by staging their cast recording after the sudden news that their show has been closed due to bad reviews. Bewildered and defeated, the ensemble cast perseveres. The climax of the episode is Paula Pell’s performance as a singer unable to nail their song, an homage to the original’s Elaine Stritch. A testament to exquisite production design, a dedicated ensemble, and a reverence for the original makes this a keeper—and even earned the admiration of . Original Cast Album: Company is available on HBO Max and Criterion Channel.

, directed by Errol Morris, challenged the codes and conventions of documentary, and this episode pays homage to that game-changer about a man wrongfully convicted of murder. The Documentary Now! twist involves the man in question being so annoying that everyone wants to pin a murder on him. Breaking from the fly-on-the-wall, observational style of past documentary traditions, the ep perfectly captures the cinematic recreations and dramatic musical score that made Morris’ film both revolutionary and controversial. Plus, it’s an ace showcase of Hader and Armisen’s comedic personas, with the former being equally seductive and menacing and the latter having the preternatural ability to exasperate.The Thin Blue Line is available on AMC+ and IFC Films Unlimited.

In response to this episode, Hader said, “Failure is something that’s hard to watch. It’s not supposed to be funny.” Perhaps this is why this one, based on the Maysles Brothers and Charlotte Zwerin’s , is the peak of cringe comedy in the series. The original film follows four traveling salesmen attempting to sell bibles across the United States, which is comically updated to globes here. Both centralize on one salesman, Paul Brennan and Armisen, respectively, who are on lengthy cold streaks. The attention to detail, down to securing the same exact film stock, is commendable. And ultimately, it is the way the parody centralizes a critique of consumer culture and capitalist enterprise that provides the punch. Following desperate people trying to sell salvation (or globes) to other desperate people is a portrait of Americans that you have to laugh at to keep from crying.Salesman is available on HBO Max and Criterion Channel.